Vegetation development over four years on two green roofs in the UK
- Authors: Bates, Adam , Sadler, Jon , Mackay, Rae
- Date: 2013
- Type: Text , Journal article
- Relation: Forestry sciences Vol. 12, no. 1 (2013), p. 98-108
- Full Text: false
- Reviewed:
- Description: Carefully designed green roofs have the potential to be used as mitigation for habitats lost at ground level. The development of plant assemblages on two green roofs designed to emulate diverse brownfield habitats (brown roofs), by using recycled demolition aggregate as part of a low-fertility growth substrate, were studied over the first four years of their development. The cover-abundance of flowering plants and habitat structural components (e.g. bare ground, moss) were measured on the Domin-Krajina scale within all identified microhabitats. Drought disturbance was one of the main controlling factors on assemblage development. Annual plants were abundant and successful in the first growth season, and thereafter only re-appeared in any numbers following drought disturbances in subsequent years. Moss and Sedum acre L. increased through the study period until these plants dominated coverage. The cover-abundance of perennial wildflower species was strongly influenced by drought disturbance. The influence of drought disturbance varied between different brown roof microhabitats, with plant assemblages in coarser and less fertile microhabitats more resistant to these disturbances. Observed responses to drought were consistent with the following two hypotheses: (i) Areas of coarse substrate can act as disturbance refugia for plants during drought by helping preserve pockets of water under large clasts and within absorbent materials such as brick. (ii) The plant assemblages living in areas of more fertile substrates, which grow more luxuriantly when water availability is high, are more vulnerable to drought disturbance. Green roofs should be designed to include a range of substrate types to create several microhabitats that will collectively support more species than any single microhabitat.
Effects of recycled aggregate growth substrate on green roof vegetation development: A six year experiment
- Authors: Bates, Adam , Sadler, Jon , Greswell, Richard , Mackay, Rae
- Date: 2015
- Type: Text , Journal article
- Relation: Landscape and Urban Planning Vol. 135, no. (2015), p. 22-31
- Full Text: false
- Reviewed:
- Description: Green roofs have the potential to address several of the environmental problems associated with urbanisation, and can be used as mitigation for habitats lost at ground level. Brown roofs (a type of green roof) can be used to mitigate for the loss of brownfield habitat, but the best way of designing these habitats remains unclear. This paper reports an experiment to test the effects of different types of recycled aggregate on the development of vegetation assemblages on brown roof mesocosms. Five recycled aggregates were tested: (1) crushed brick, (2) crushed demolition aggregate, (3) solid municipal waste incinerator bottom ash aggregate, (4) a 1:1 mix of 1 and 2, and (5) a 1:1 mix of 3 and 2. Each was seeded with a wildflower mix that also included some Sedum acre and vegetation development was studied over a six-year period. Species richness, assemblage character, number of plants able to seed, and plant biomass were measured. Drought disturbance was the key factor controlling changes in plant assemblage, but effects varied with substrate treatment. All treatments supported a similar plant biomass, but treatments with a high proportion of crushed brick in the growth substrate supported richer assemblages, with more species able to seed, and a smaller amount of Sedum acre. Crushed brick, or recycled aggregates with a high proportion of crushed brick, are recommended as good growth substrate materials for encouraging brown roof plant diversity. This investigation demonstrates the importance of multi-year studies of green roof development for the generation of robust findings.
An initial experimental assessment of the influence of substrate depth on floral assemblage for extensive green roofs
- Authors: Olly, Luke , Bates, Adam , Sadler, Jon , Mackay, Rae
- Date: 2011
- Type: Text , Journal article
- Relation: Urban Forestry and Urban Greening Vol. 10, no. 4 (2011), p. 311-316
- Full Text: false
- Reviewed:
- Description: Extensive green roofs have the potential to be used as mitigation tools to compensate for urban habitat loss, but there is little information about how closely these systems emulate ground-based habitats. This study investigated the effect of limited substrate depth on plant assemblages in the initial phase of growth in extensive green roof substrates. Five replicate mesocosms (1m 2) for each of three design treatments: (A) 10cm aggregate depth with green roof drainage and solid floor, (B) 15cm aggregate depth with green roof drainage and solid floor, and (C) 15cm aggregate depth on top of bare earth; were positioned at ground level. Each mesocosm had an identical growth substrate and was seeded with the same seed mix. Plant assemblages were analysed using point-quadrat methods. Significant differences in species composition were observed between treatments that seemed to be related to water availability. Even the deep (15cm) solid floor green roof treatment showed many significant differences in floral assemblage compared to the identical treatment (C) where plants had access to water in the soil profile. Therefore, it is not possible to exactly recreate most ground-based urban habitats on roofs by simply copying the soil characteristics and floral composition found on the ground. Like for mitigation for habitat loss using extensive green roofs requires the careful manipulation of design elements in order to counteract the limited water availability on green roofs. © 2011 Elsevier GmbH.
Effects of varying organic matter content on the development of green roof vegetation: A six year experiment
- Authors: Bates, Adam , Sadler, Jon , Greswell, Richard , Mackay, Rae
- Date: 2015
- Type: Text , Journal article
- Relation: Ecological Engineering Vol. 82, no. September (2015), p. 301-310
- Full Text: false
- Reviewed:
- Description: Green roofs can potentially be used to tackle a variety of environmental problems, and can be used as development mitigation for the loss of ground-based habitats. Brown (biodiversity) roofs are a type of green roof designed to imitate brownfield habitat, but the best way of engineering these habitats requires more research. We tested the effects of altering organic matter content on the development of vegetation assemblages of experimental brown (biodiversity) roof mesocosms. Three mulch treatments were tested: (1) sandy loam, where 10 mm of sandy loam mulch (about 3% organic matter by dry weight) was added to 100 mm of recycled aggregate; (2) compost, where the mulch also contained some garden compost (about 6% organic matter by dry weight); and (3) no mulch, where no mulch was added. Mesocosms were seeded with a wildflower mix that included some Sedum acre, and vegetation development was investigated over a six-year period. Species richness, assemblage character, number of plants able to seed, and above-ground plant biomass were measured. Drought disturbance was an important control on plant assemblages in all mulch treatments, but there were significant treatment response interactions. The more productive compost treatment was associated with larger plant coverage and diversity before the occurrence of a sequence of drought disturbances, but was more strongly negatively affected by the disturbances than the two less productive treatments. We suggest that this was due to the over-production of plant biomass in the more productive treatment, which made the plants more vulnerable to the effects of drought disturbance, leading to a kind of 'boom-bust' assemblage dynamic. The 'ideal' amount of added organic matter for these green roof systems was very low, but other types of green roof that have a larger water holding capacity, and/or more drought resistant plant floras, will likely require more organic matter or fertiliser. Nonetheless, nutrient-supported productivity in green roof systems should be kept low in order to avoid boom-bust plant assemblage dynamics. Research into the best way of engineering green roof habitats should take place over a long enough multi-year time period to include the effects of temporally infrequent disturbances. © 2015 Elsevier B.V.